Geoffrey was killed when you look at the a biking crash in 1186 and you can Constance hitched (2) Ranulph de- Blundeville, cuatro th Earl from Chester, towards step 3 rd March 1188, into the a marriage establish by the Queen Henry 11. That it marriage deteriorated and you may Ranulph imprisoned Constance within the 1196. Rebellions was in fact sparked all over Brittany on her and you will Ranulph put-out their in 1198. Back in Brittany, Constance got their relationship annulled and soon after in 1198, she grabbed Man de Trips since the their particular ‘second’ husband.
Constance died old forty, (perhaps off leprosy, maybe following childbirth to dual girls) towards 5 th Sep 1201 during the Nantes
Even though this was not a good consanguineous matchmaking however, one of affinity, one very first-knowledge relationships could have made matrimony between Constance and you will some of John’s brothers impossible instead a beneficial dispensation –– and this considering the party’s review would have had to are from new pope themselves
The concept one to Constance had an affair which have John after the death of Geoffrey and you may ahead of John’s matrimony in order to Isabella regarding Gloucester from inside the 1189, and that she are mother to Joanna is very controversial and you will possess provoked far talk within this genealogical circles.
One comment regarding a great genealogist claims one ‘new diary ‘New Plantagenet Connection’ keeps wrote an enthusiastic ahnentafel of E Plantagenet, wife from Henry V11, that gives Joanna’s mom’s name as the Constance (possibly misnamed Clemence?), Duchess out of Brittany. This is actually the Constance who was John’s sis-in-laws! As a result of the better-recognized animosity anywhere between John and you can Constance along with her individual tries to press their young buck Arthur’s welfare in terms of this new throne out-of England is concerned (therefore we every recognize how disastrously you to turned out!), I really select the proposed matchmaking a tiny hard to ingest. New Constance one to records depicts will not strike myself due to the fact into just who John can potentially coerce into the bed.’
‘ A principle that would select Joanna’s mommy because Constance fails to take into account an incredibly critical reason for cannon laws. That would imply that particular shadow of one’s matter need surely attended right down to you, if this with it the obtain it, the latest deliberations, and/or real dispensation in itself. As much as i was alert, nothing of your own type can be obtained.’
By the merely having sex with John, let-alone results him a child, Constance would have built a first-training matchmaking out of attraction with John’s sisters –– also John’s cousin Geoffrey
My very own viewpoint for just what it’s value, is that got Constance been mom away from Joanna she’d seriously possess delivered their particular upwards in her own household along with her name would-be also called Constance’s other youngsters because of the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Fair Maid out of Brittany, Matilda/Maud of Brittany and you can Arthur).
Agatha was born regarding the 1168 in the Chartley Palace, Staffordshire. It is infamous one to she try a domme from John and lots of friends trees offer her, though solitary, since mother off Joanna. Really genealogists yet not are of the opinion that it’s simply conjecture you to the woman is Joanna’s mom due to the fact no evidence otherwise info occur to exhibit which.
That origin seem to offered try Sir William Dugdale, throughout the Baronage out-of England (1675-6). He says their source as Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation for Wales’ (1584). Powell’s work is an increased release out-of H Lloyd’s interpretation of ‘The latest Historie of Cambria’ by the 12 th century Saint Caradoc of Llancarfan. A unique origin, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ because of the Charles Browning, copyright laws 1969 together with brands Agatha de- Ferrers, child out of Robert de- Ferrers, fourth Earl out of derby, since Joanna’s mommy.
No matter if brightwomen she cannot be completely ignored since an applicant getting mommy of Joanna, undoubtedly there would be specific shadow off their when you look at the a great chronicle and other historic site, if the she got actually been the caretaker of the partner away from the brand new Prince of Northern Wales.